Home/Compare/Heat pump or gas furnace: working out which costs less to run
Heat pump or gas furnace: working out which costs less to run
Which is cheaper isn't a matter of opinion. It falls out of your gas price, your electricity price, the furnace's efficiency and how well the heat pump copes with your winters. Here's how to run the numbers.
Efficiency criteria and sources checked 25 September 2026
Divide your gas price per therm by the furnace's efficiency. Then take your electricity price per kWh, times 29.31, divided by the heat pump's efficiency (its COP) at the temperatures you actually see. The lower number heats your house for less. When power is cheap next to gas, the heat pump usually wins most of the winter. When power is pricey, the furnace can win on the coldest days. Dual fuel pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace as backup, so the house runs on whichever is cheaper at each outdoor temperature.
The one formula that settles it
One therm of gas holds 100,000 BTU. The same amount of heat is 29.31 kWh of electricity, since 1 kWh equals 3,412 BTU. Now both fuels are on the same scale.
For the furnace, cost per 100,000 BTU delivered = gas price per therm ÷ AFUE (as a decimal). A 95% furnace burning $1.40 gas comes out around $1.47 per 100,000 BTU.
For the heat pump, cost per 100,000 BTU delivered = electricity price per kWh × 29.31 ÷ COP. At $0.15 per kWh and a COP of 3, you land at about $1.47 as well. A tie.
Those are round numbers to show the method, not today's averages. Use the rates on your own bills, delivery charges included. The EIA publishes state averages for both fuels if you want something to compare against.
The break-even COP
Rearranging the formula gives the COP a heat pump needs just to match the furnace: break-even COP = 29.31 × electricity price × AFUE ÷ gas price.
| Electricity | Gas $1.00/therm | Gas $1.40/therm | Gas $2.00/therm |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0.10/kWh | 2.8 | 2.0 | 1.4 |
| $0.15/kWh | 4.2 | 3.0 | 2.1 |
| $0.20/kWh | 5.6 | 4.0 | 2.8 |
| $0.25/kWh | 7.0 | 5.0 | 3.5 |
That's why the answer changes from region to region. Cheap power and expensive gas? A heat pump at a COP of 2 already wins. Expensive power and cheap gas, and it would need a COP most equipment can't hit in cold weather.
Why outdoor temperature matters
A furnace's efficiency barely moves with the weather. A heat pump's does. It's pulling heat out of colder and colder air, so its COP and its capacity both drop with the temperature. The same unit can be cheap to run at 40 °F and expensive at 0 °F.
ENERGY STAR's cold-climate label gives you a floor. To qualify, a heat pump must reach a COP of at least 1.75 at 5 °F and deliver at least 70% of its 47 °F heating capacity at 5 °F, confirmed with its own controls running. NEEP publishes a searchable list of cold-climate models with tested figures at several temperatures.
For a rough estimate, use the seasonal rating. HSPF2 is BTU of heat per watt-hour across a standard heating season, so dividing it by 3.412 gives an approximate seasonal COP. An HSPF2 of 8.5 works out to about 2.5. The test assumes a moderate climate. In a cold region, expect less.
Two different balance points
The thermal balance point is the outdoor temperature where the house loses heat as fast as the heat pump can make it. Below that, you need backup heat from electric resistance strips or a furnace. Resistance strips run at a COP of 1. That's why they cost so much.
The economic balance point is different. It's the outdoor temperature where the heat pump's cost per unit of heat climbs to match the furnace's, found by setting the break-even COP above against the heat pump's COP at each temperature. In some regions it's colder than any winter you'll see. In others it sits well above freezing.
Dual fuel: using both
A dual-fuel (or hybrid) system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace and flips between them at an outdoor temperature you set in the thermostat or control. The heat pump carries the mild months. Below the switchover, the furnace takes over. Put that switchover at your economic balance point and you pay the lower rate every day of the season.
It fits homes that already have gas and ductwork, in places with long, cold winters. The heat pump doubles as the central AC, so if you're replacing an old AC anyway, you pick up heating capacity for part of what a separate heat pump system would cost. The downsides: two machines to maintain, and a monthly gas connection fee you keep paying even when you barely burn any gas.
Beyond the running cost
A heat pump cools as well as heats. A furnace needs a separate AC for summer.
Drop gas completely and the monthly meter fee goes with it. Keep even one gas appliance and you keep paying it.
Anything that burns fuel needs venting and combustion air, and residential codes generally require carbon monoxide alarms in homes that have one.
Watch your electrical capacity. A heat pump, especially one with resistance backup, can push an older panel or service close to its limit. Get the load calculated before you buy.
On incentives, the federal 25C tax credit is gone for equipment placed in service after 31 December 2025. Utility and state programs vary, so check yours before choosing.
Which fits your house
- Heat pump alone where power is cheap next to gas, winters are mild to moderate, or there's no gas service. In cold regions, get a cold-climate model.
- Gas furnace alone where gas is cheap, electricity is expensive, you already have a working AC, and the break-even COP for your rates is out of reach.
- Dual fuel where you already have gas and ducts, winters are long, and the economic balance point lands in the middle of your heating season.
What we have not verified yet
Everything above comes from the document linked alongside it or from a unit conversion shown on the page. These are the open questions, listed so you know where this page stops:
- Installed cost ranges for each option by region
- Measured real-world seasonal COP by climate zone, as opposed to rated HSPF2
- How time-of-use and tiered electricity rates change the break-even figures
- Maintenance and service-life differences based on published data, not rules of thumb
Common questions
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?
It depends on your energy prices and climate. Compare electricity price per kWh times 29.31 divided by the heat pump's COP against gas price per therm divided by the furnace's AFUE. The lower figure is the cheaper heat.
At what temperature should a dual-fuel system switch to gas?
At your economic balance point: the outdoor temperature where the heat pump's cost per unit of heat rises above the furnace's. Work out the break-even COP from your rates, then find the temperature where your heat pump's rated COP drops to that level.
Do heat pumps work in very cold weather?
Cold-climate models do, at reduced efficiency. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate criteria require a COP of at least 1.75 and at least 70% of rated capacity at 5 °F. Below the house's thermal balance point, backup heat is still needed.
What is a good COP for a heat pump?
COP changes with outdoor temperature, so compare it at a stated temperature. At 5 °F, a cold-climate unit must reach at least 1.75. As a seasonal figure, dividing HSPF2 by 3.412 gives an approximate average.